MW Why Apple shareholders may want the Tim Cook era to come to a close

By Jurica Dujmovic

Does Apple's current leadership possess the necessary vision and agility to manage a challenging AI future?

Under Cook's leadership, Apple has become akin to a luxury liner: impressive, comfortable (and immensely profitable), but arguably slow to change course.

As the tech industry accelerates into uncharted territory around artificial intelligence and other transformative innovations, Apple $(AAPL)$ is at a crossroads. The company must decide whether to stay its current course of careful iteration or to reignite the revolutionary spirit that once made it the world's most exciting tech company.

This decision may well determine whether Apple retains its crown as a tech leader or becomes a cautionary tale of a giant that failed to keep pace with the very future it once helped create.

Does Apple's current leadership possess the necessary vision and agility to manage these challenges? The contrast between the Steve Jobs era and Tim Cook's tenure is stark. Where Jobs was a tech visionary who consistently pushed Apple to redefine entire industries, Cook has expertly refined Apple into a precision-engineered profit machine.

Under Cook's leadership, Apple has become akin to a luxury liner: impressive, comfortable (and immensely profitable), but arguably slow to change course. This approach has served the company and its shareholders well, but as technological change picks up speed, Apple's ability to navigate is being called into question.

Cook's strength lies in operational excellence and incremental improvements, evidenced by Apple's consistently polished products and robust ecosystem. However, this focus on perfecting existing formulas may be coming at the cost of the bold, industry-shaking innovations that once defined Apple.

Apple's deliberate pace of innovation risks it falling behind more agile competitors. The question now looming over Apple is whether Cook's leadership style, which prioritizes refinement and reliability, can adapt to an era that demands radical innovation and swift pivots.

Apple's archrival Samsung Electronics (KR:005930) has reclaimed the top spot in global smartphone shipments, holding a 20% market share over Apple in the first quarter of 2024. The South Korean tech giant's success is attributed to its diverse product lineup, including the well-received Galaxy S24 series and refreshed Galaxy A-series. By offering innovative features across various price points, Samsung has successfully challenged Apple's dominance in the premium segment.

The time may be approaching for Apple to consider a changing of the guard.

The time may be approaching for Apple to consider a changing of the guard - to seek leadership that can blend Cook's operational mastery with a renewed appetite for groundbreaking innovation. The tech world is no longer content with incremental updates wrapped in sleek designs; it hungers for the next big leap. Apple needs to rediscover its role not just as a maker of premium devices, but as the architect of tomorrow's technological paradigms.

Consider Apple's recent product cycles, especially in its flagship iPhone series. The iPhone 14, 15 and recently introduced 16 series, while polished and high-quality, lack bold innovations. Features such as titanium design, slightly larger displays, and camera enhancements such as the 48-megapixel Fusion camera improve user experience but don't represent the paradigm-shifting innovations that once defined Apple's product launches.

Rivals have pushed ahead with advanced AI capabilities and foldable displays - a market projected to grow to $13.2 billion in 2029, from $4.6 billion in 2024 - a 23.6% compound annual growth rate, according to research from MarketsandMarkets. Apple, meanwhile, has focused mainly on modest camera upgrades and slightly faster processors, missing the opportunity to lead in emerging tech trends.

Emerging markets, where price sensitivity is high, are a prime example. Affordable Android devices are rapidly gaining market share in Africa, Latin America and Asia. Their success highlights a key weakness in Apple's strategy: Its premium pricing limits its reach in these high-growth markets.

Apple previously offered more affordable options through its S series phones, which provided incremental updates at lower price points, but this effort has been largely abandoned. The iPhone SE, Apple's current lower-cost option, struggles to compete with feature-rich, affordable Android devices due to its dated design. Apple's one-size-fits-all approach to product development and pricing doesn't meet the diverse needs of global markets, particularly in emerging economies where affordability is a key factor. The company's strong ecosystem, while a significant strength, may also be hindering its ability to make radical changes that could disrupt its existing product lines and services.

Perhaps most notably, Apple's visible integration of AI technologies into its products has been slower compared with Alphabet's Google $(GOOGL)$ and Samsung. This lag is particularly noticeable in an era when AI capabilities are becoming a key differentiator for smartphones.

To maintain its position and relevance in the evolving smartphone market, Apple must consider several strategic moves.

To maintain its position and relevance in the evolving smartphone market, Apple must consider several strategic moves.

First and foremost, the company needs to accelerate its AI integration. This means expediting the rollout of AI-driven features in its iPhone lineup, while still prioritizing privacy and controlled ecosystem integration.

Apple should develop and showcase unique AI capabilities that align with its privacy-centric ethos and invest in local AI partnerships, especially in key markets. These include the U.S., where Apple can leverage its strong presence to introduce privacy-focused AI features that resonate with tech-savvy consumers. In China, despite regulatory challenges, partnering with local AI companies could help Apple tailor its offerings to compete more effectively against domestic brands like Huawei and Xiaomi (HK:1810). India's rapidly growing smartphone market presents an opportunity for Apple to develop AI features that cater to local needs, such as advanced language processing and social-media-oriented camera enhancements. In Europe, where privacy regulations are stringent, Apple's AI initiatives could focus on strengthening its reputation for data security. Southeast Asian markets such as Indonesia and Vietnam offer potential for AI features tailored to improving connectivity and battery management, which would appeal to the region's expanding middle class.

Apple's traditional approach of perfecting technologies before launch also needs to evolve. The company should adopt a more aggressive innovation cycle with more frequent updates and experimental releases. This might involve embracing calculated risks by entering new product categories earlier, even if products are not fully perfected, and establishing innovation hubs in key global markets to tap into diverse talent pools and stay attuned to regional tech trends.

While innovating, Apple must continue to reinforce its ecosystem advantages. This means enhancing cross-device functionality to create seamless experiences that lock in user loyalty, developing exclusive features and services that are only available within the Apple ecosystem, and expanding partnerships with developers and content creators to ensure a rich and varied app and content ecosystem.

The challenge for Apple lies in balancing its premium brand positioning with the need to innovate at the pace demanded by today's consumers. The company must find ways to maintain its reputation for quality and reliability while also pushing the boundaries of technology. This could involve creating innovation tiers and product lines that cater to different levels of technological adoption, from cutting-edge experimental devices to more traditional, refined products.

Embracing open innovation could also be beneficial, with Apple collaborating more transparently with third-party developers and researchers to accelerate innovation in key areas including AI, augmented reality and virtual reality. Investing in next-generation technologies such as quantum computing, biotechnology integration and advanced materials science also could help Apple stay ahead of long-term tech trends.

Enhanced transparency about its innovation pipeline could help Apple build anticipation and demonstrate the company's commitment to pushing technological boundaries. This approach could help reassure investors and consumers alike that Apple remains at the forefront of technological innovation.

Plus: Apple Intelligence is key to new iPhone sales, but don't expect a big revenue jolt right away

More: Apple's Steve Jobs was a rare breed - here's why many charismatic tech CEOs fail

-Jurica Dujmovic

This content was created by MarketWatch, which is operated by Dow Jones & Co. MarketWatch is published independently from Dow Jones Newswires and The Wall Street Journal.

(END) Dow Jones Newswires

November 02, 2024 12:34 ET (16:34 GMT)

Copyright (c) 2024 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.