e.l.f. Beauty, Inc. ELF has long been celebrated for its impressive growth trajectory, but its current valuation raises concerns. The company’s forward 12-month price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio stands at 38.79, significantly outpacing the S&P 500’s P/E of 22 and the industry average of 26.94. Such a sharp contrast raises the question: Is ELF’s stock price justified, or is it overvalued? Adding to investor concerns is the company’s Value Score of F, which suggests its premium may be difficult to sustain.

ELF Stock Appears Overvalued

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

ELF Stock Falling Behind in the Market

e.l.f. Beauty’s stock has taken a hit, declining 37.3% over the past six months — worse than the cosmetics industry’s 34.1% drop. This slump becomes even steeper compared to the broader Zacks Consumer Staples sector, which fell only 0.5%, and the S&P 500, which rose 7.7%. Such underperformance reflects waning confidence in ELF’s ability to navigate today’s challenges.

ELF Price Performance vs. Industry, S&P 500 & Sector

Image Source: Zacks Investment Research

What’s Stealing the Radiance From e.l.f. Beauty?

The beauty industry is grappling with significant headwinds. Rising inflation, cautious spending and evolving consumer preferences have created a tough operating environment. The U.S. color cosmetics market shrank by 5% in the second quarter of fiscal 2025, accelerating from a 1% decline in the prior quarter. While e.l.f. Beauty managed a 16% growth rate in U.S. tracked channels, it fell short of its 20% target, illustrating how market pressures are impacting even the strongest players.

Competition has also intensified. Big names like The Estee Lauder Companies EL continue to dominate with extensive resources, while indie brands are carving out market share with niche appeal and clever digital marketing. The growing popularity of clean beauty and premiumization trends has spurred consumers to explore alternative offerings, intensifying the need for e.l.f. Beauty to innovate and distinguish itself.

To stay competitive, companies such as e.l.f. Beauty are increasing investments in marketing, workforce expansion and strategic acquisitions to strengthen their competitive edge. However, these initiatives come with significant costs, particularly during economic uncertainty. e.l.f. Beauty's SG&A expenses rose to 53% of net sales in the second quarter, up from 45% in the same period last year, reflecting higher marketing spending, team growth and costs associated with integrating Naturium. Elevated operational expenses can place pressure on profitability, especially as sales growth moderates in key markets.

Strengths That Keep e.l.f. Beauty in the Spotlight

e.l.f. Beauty’s unwavering commitment to innovation places it on the growth trajectory. The company continuously leverages consumer insights and trends to develop high-quality, competitively priced products that resonate with its audience. Signature offerings such as the Power Grip Primer and Halo Glow continue to lead their categories, while a robust pipeline ensures the portfolio remains fresh and aligned with evolving consumer preferences.

e.l.f. Beauty has also been proactive in expanding its retail footprint, enhancing brand visibility and accessibility. By securing additional shelf space with major partners like Target TGT and Dollar General DG, the brand has increased its presence in high-traffic urban areas and underserved rural markets. This strategic expansion supports the company’s mission of making premium beauty products accessible to a broader audience.

Recognizing the growth potential of e-commerce, e.l.f. Beauty has made significant investments to enhance its digital platforms. Digital sales grew 40% year over year in the second quarter, now representing 20% of total sales, up from 17% in the prior year. The company’s Beauty Squad Loyalty Program, which has grown to 5.3 million members — a 30% annual increase — has been instrumental in driving digital success through initiatives such as early access to product launches and strengthened digital partnerships.

e.l.f. Beauty’s 23 consecutive quarters of market share gains underscore its leadership in the cosmetics industry. In the second quarter of fiscal 2025, the company gained 195 basis points (bps) of U.S. market share, building on a 330-bps increase from the prior year. This sustained momentum reflects the strength of its compelling value proposition, radical product portfolio and highly effective marketing strategies.

Can ELF Reignite Confidence?

e.l.f. Beauty raised its fiscal 2025 guidance in its second-quarter earnings release, reflecting optimism about its future. The company now expects net sales to grow 28-30%, up from its previous range of 25-27%. Adjusted EBITDA is forecasted to rise to the $304-$308 million band, an increase from the earlier projection of $297-$301 million. These revised figures underscore management’s confidence in e.l.f. Beauty’s ability to execute its strategies effectively.

ELF Stock: Finding the Path Forward

e.l.f. Beauty’s journey is a mix of challenges and opportunities. While its valuation and rising costs raise concerns, its innovative product lineup, expanding retail presence and strong digital performance highlight its potential for a turnaround. The company’s ability to adapt to evolving market dynamics will be critical as it strives to balance growth with profitability. For now, e.l.f. Beauty remains a compelling story that requires careful watching as it navigates the next chapter. The company currently carries a Zacks Rank #3 (Hold). You can see the complete list of today’s Zacks #1 Rank (Strong Buy) stocks here.

Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research? Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click to get this free report

Target Corporation (TGT) : Free Stock Analysis Report

Dollar General Corporation (DG) : Free Stock Analysis Report

The Estee Lauder Companies Inc. (EL) : Free Stock Analysis Report

e.l.f. Beauty (ELF) : Free Stock Analysis Report

To read this article on Zacks.com click here.

Zacks Investment Research